Is There an Afterlife?

The literature on death is voluminous and deserving of its own book length study. What we can do here is briefly discuss a few of the issues involved. Belief in immortality is widespread, as anthropological studies reveal, but most people regard death as the ultimate tragedy and crave continued existence. Yet there is little if any evidence for immortality; and we do not personally know anyone who came back from the dead to tell us about an afterlife. Still, many people cling to any indirect evidence they can—near death experiences, belief in reincarnation, ghost stories, communication with the dead, and the like. The problem is that none of this so-called evidence stands up well to critical scrutiny. It is so much more likely that the propensity of individuals to deceive or be deceived explains such beliefs, than that these phenomena are real. Those who accept such evidence are most likely grasping at straws—engaging in wishful thinking.

Modern science generally ignores this so-called evidence for an afterlife for a number of reasons. First, the supposedly immortal soul plays no explanatory or predictive role in the modern science. Second, overwhelming evidence supports the view that consciousness ceases when brain functioning does. If ghosts or disembodied spirits exist, then we would be forced to rethink much of modern science—such as the belief that consciousness cannot exist without matter.

Of course this cursory treatment of the issue does not establish that an afterlife is impossible, especially since that possibility depends on answers to complicated philosophical questions about personal identity and the mind-body problem. But suffice it to say that explaining either the dualistic theory of life after death—where the soul separates from the body at death and lives forever—or the monist theory—where a new glorified body related to the earthly body lives on forever—is extraordinarily difficult. In the first case substance dualism must be defended, and in the second case the miraculous idea of the new body must be explained. Either way the philosophical task is enormous. Clearly the scientific winds are blowing against these ancient beliefs.

Still when asked about what one thinks about an afterlife, a reasonable response is to reply that one is all for it—assuming it’s pleasant! If it turns out that when we die we really do move to a better neighborhood … great. Yet it is easy to see that this is very unlikely.

Liked it? Take a second to support Dr John Messerly on Patreon!

1 thought on “Is There an Afterlife?

  1. All excellent arguments, of course.

    “most people regard death as the ultimate tragedy and crave continued existence”.

    An excellent point. I think this pretty much proves that people desperately want to BELIEVE that there’s no such a thing as “ultimate death”, yet in their HEART they feel quite unsure about the belief!

    I was speaking to a “theist” (mostly by chance) after he had asked a question (don’t remind what.) Admittedly, his beliefs were not predictable, as he has a strange or original idea of “God”. To him, God is not the predictable entity that is commonly believed (guess why? Because he has no explanations about our existence, for example the reason why we are here “is a mystery”.

    He was mentioning near death experiences. I immediately made a powerful argument about an experiment that I had read about years ago, which consisted of placing a big picture of Jesus on the roof, that was not visible from the ground. Before long, the doctors found the next “near deather” who absolutely believed he floated, saw the doctors on the ground, then went through a tunnel, etc etc. When he was asked if he saw anything striking, his answer was no.

    The answer or my theist: “Oh yes. I knew of these experiments. But these are only a few cases.”.

    Most prefer fairy tales to the naked truth, and they are extremely common as you know.

    Thanks for your excellent article.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.