Depression: Whose Fault Is It?

A man diagnosed as suffering from melancholia with strong su Wellcome L0026693.jpg

I was recently involved in a discussion about someone who had committed suicide. I don’t know the details but evidently, the victim was a successful, mid-career man, suffering from depression. A major contributing factor was job stress. Here is how the dialogue went. (I’m CG) :

A Tough Guy (TG)- The guy was stupid and weak-minded. He needed to master his thoughts. If his job was stressful, he should have gotten another one. If his thoughts were troubling, he should change them.  If you can’t stand the heat get out of the kitchen.

A Compassionate Guy (CG) – Depression can strike anyone, it is a disease. If you experience enough stress you can have a mental breakdown. Just spend a few hours in a war zone or a few years in a stressful job and you can find out for yourself. If possible you should avoid bad situations, but you can’t always do that. Depressed persons need compassion and professional help.

TG – If you really care about someone tell them not to put themselves in situations where they might get hurt.

CG – Sure. But if they’re already suffering from mental illness it’s too late.   By that time they are then in a situation which is beyond their control.  At that point free will, if it exists, can’t intervene.

A Former Depressed Guy (FS) – When you are suffering from depression you can’t think rationally, just like when you are physically ill you can’t perform certain physical tasks. Friends helped me get help before I had my own breakdown, but many aren’t that lucky.
A Social Scientist (SS) – It’s problematic to insinuate that the fault with depression or suicide lies within the person. One million people decide to take their lives every year, that’s 1.5% of all deaths worldwide. The problem is the system. Many want to get out of the kitchen, but they can’t because the kitchen is the whole world.  So we should destroy the kitchen, and rebuild it so that it doesn’t burn us anymore.
An Economist (E) – It’s clear that the developed world faces issues related to stress—largely driven by capitalistic modes of production which have reduced the value of individual human experience.  Here is an article about South Korea that makes the point.
TG – Don’t blame the world; blame yourself. You decided to become stressed. So change yourself.
SS – We need societal structural change which leads to individual change, which in turn leads to societal change. We need a society based on a new social contract that meets people’s biological and psychological needs. A world where people aren’t forced into competitive environments.  A cooperative society based more on social capital than economic capital. A society with work that is stable and psychologically fulfilling.
TG – Until then if you can’t stand the heat get out of the kitchen.
CG – That’s what this talented man did.  He followed your advice. That’s not an indictment of him, even by your own standards. It’s an indictment of the world. We need to rethink the world.
Liked it? Take a second to support Dr John Messerly on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

6 thoughts on “Depression: Whose Fault Is It?

  1. Brilliant! I always wonder how come high functioning adults who have average social network who are able, and prone to, metaphysical discussions about the meaning of life at or leading up to their depressive states, but shy from discussing their suicidal fantasies. Talking to people can be cathartic yet suicidal thought are taboo, Taboos are by nature socially constructed boundaries set by pious and clergymen – it has to be shattered

  2. As someone who has sought, and benefited from, medical help with depression, and suicidal thinking, I am grateful for this piece. Thanks.

  3. IMO, it is both the person and their environment. People underestimate the effect of their environment on their psyche. I would say that suicide is a right, but should never be attempted until you exhaust other options like working out and eating right and cutting out toxic influence. I feel like cognitive rehabilitation therapy works and should be encouraged more than the prescription drugs.

  4. Those who are lost can’t save themselves because the depression has taken away there ability to rationalize there own situation. For them they don’t see or know how to get out of the situation at hand.

  5. Schopenhauer thought that if we really had to face life without all our little distractions most if not all of us would choose suicide at some point in our lives. Personally, considering how hopelessly difficult suicide is for most humans due to instinctual, psychological and cultural factors, suicide is only for the most courageous and honest of humans at least much of the time. I know this from experience. I have wanted out more times than I can count but never had the guts to face that reality. I hope there comes a point where I do find the courage. If not it’s very likely I’ll meet death in a hospital bed where fluids are dripped into and out of every orifice while my life savings and my children’s inheritance is drained away. Dying like that is IMO beyond shameful and cowardly and the path taken by most of humanity when it’s made available. Don’t call the suicide a coward, you’re just trying to make yourself feel good with the cultural lie.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.