Summary of Feminism on Human Nature

(This is my summary of a chapter in a book I often used in university classes: Thirteen Theories of Human Nature, by Stevenson, Haberman, and Wright, Oxford Univ. Press.)

Traditionally theories of human nature are conceived of by men and seem to equate human nature with male nature. Some of these thinkers believed that women were just different from men; others that they were inferior.

There are two basic responses from feminist theory. Humanist feminists believe that the notion of a shared human nature is valuable even if it didn’t accommodate sexual differences. Such humanists emphasize a core human nature that women and men share. In this view, traditional theories go wrong when they ignore this common nature or suggest that women can’t fulfill that nature as men can.

The second view, social constructionist, derives from the work of the 20th-century philosopher Simone de Beauvior. She argues that gender is a socially constructed rather than biological category: “One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman.” ( suppose there are various socially constructed ideas of maleness too.) She also believed that women often don’t experience full selfhood because of oppressive social constraints.

But both views believe in a common human nature, and that social and political change is needed to remove the constraints on woman fully developing this nature.

Feminist Philosophy and Feminism 

Feminist philosophy supports female equality and opposes oppression of women. Feminism as a political movement grew out of feminist philosophy—emphasizing the right to vote or working for abolitionist, antiwar, or disarmament. While political feminism stresses action and political change, feminist philosophy seeks to understand the nature of inequality and the oppression of women.

Contemporary Humanist Feminism

CHF stresses the equality of men and women, demanding equal treatment for women. Thus they are skeptical of notions of justice that omit consideration of private family life, the context of much of women’s oppression—-unpaid housework, maternal care, submission to their husbands, etc. Other humanistic feminists emphasize the equality of opportunity. Societies should be so arranged as to provide the conditions under which all citizens can actualize the potential inherent in their natures.

Neohumanist Feminism and Dehumanization

Can the notion of dehumanization shed light on the value of a shared human nature? Some feminists argue that the concept of dehumanization captures what is morally wrong with discrimination, domination, and oppression against any group. Dehumanization can be directed at anyone, and it is also connected to justice. Justice is about equality in family life, the chance to develop one’s capacities, the right not to be treated inhumanely, and more. In the end, justice must spring from a consideration of our shared human nature.

Critical Perspectives on Humanist Feminism 

Some feminists criticize humanist feminism as ignoring the differences between men and women by adopting traditional male conceptions of human nature. Others argue that human nature is defined either from an external biological perspective, which doesn’t make moral prescriptions or an internal notion that reduces to morality to individual subjective values. One solution to this problem would be to recognize that biology and moral norms can be joined since we are all by nature social beings. After all, human beings are interdependent, as the feminist have always emphasized.

My Reflection – The world would immediately improve if half of all social, political, governmental positions were filled by women.

Liked it? Take a second to support Dr John Messerly on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

5 thoughts on “Summary of Feminism on Human Nature

  1. At this time, men have no intention of relinquishing their power over women– and this is not a generalization. Trump and his ilk are merely proof-positive of such.

  2. ”The world would immediately improve if half of all social, political, governmental positions were filled by women.”.

    And the question is, why is it not? What is stopping these women from doing anything?

    I respectfully disagree, and totally. The world would immediately improve if social, political, and governmental positions are filled by the people who 1. have the best skills for the job, and 2. cared to show up.

    Who is a man, and who a woman: why should anyone really care? Most feminism is simply hysteria.

    Once upon a time, feminism was truly about defending rights. Now most of it is simply an excuse to engage in childish histrionics.

    Interestingly, very few really care about women who suffer real discrimination, and real injustice, for example those in certain countries.

    And ultimately, whether it’s (real, not imagined) discrimination against women, racism, discrimination against minorities, LGBT, whatever…. unless it is truly affecting one directly, why care?

    I encountered discrimination too, I never really cared that much. I simply shrugged. The only people I often understand, is black people. Let’s face it, they have taken a lot of trash in the past, and even today they aren’t immune from it.

    Not women.

    Unless it is about serious abuse, they’d better read Marcus Aurelius: ‘Stop believing you have been harmed, and you haven’t.’.

  3. PS. And I am not saying that sexism doesn’t exists in first world countries. It does. But the whole thing about how men built a world for men, and it is all a conspiracy against women, the martyrs of society, is just ridiculous hysteria.

  4. I apologize for my somewhat more combative comments in this post. I admire you even more than before. Even though we don’t know each other in person, there’s something in your composure and mental clarity I really like. Mines are no match.

    I have never found anyone on the internet like you. It is me the one who would be disappointing in person, not you.

    Thank you….for all !


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.