![]()
MORAL LUCK
by Larry Houlgate**
What is it and what would the classic philosophers have to say about it?
It would be best to start with an example of moral luck. Imagine two teenagers (Mark and Susan) who have challenged each other to a race in their new hot rods. The race is scheduled for midnight at a one mile two-lane strip of road outside of town. Hundreds of other teenagers hear about the race.
They line up on both sides of the road to witness the race.But what they witness is tragedy. Neither Mark nor Susan saw the oil slick 100 meters ahead of the starting place. While still accelerating, Mark lost control of his car. The car careened into the crowd, killing one person and injuring many more.
Susan also lost control but luckily her car crashed into a thicket of bushes on the other side of the road and hit no bystanders.
It is factors beyond their control that significantly influences how much blame Mark and Susan deserve that define the notion of moral luck. Although both Mark and Susan will both be blamed for reckless driving, Mark is likely to be judged much more harshly. The consequences of his loss of control were much greater than the consequences of Susan’s loss of control. Mark killed and injured people. Susan didn’t harm anyone.
Mark: “Hey dude. I admit that I was reckless but I didn’t intend to hurt anyone. I didn’t see the oil slick. I lost control of my car. All I wanted to do was show off my hot rod.”
Susan: “”Ditto, I admit that I was reckless but I didn’t hurt anyone.”
Mark was unlucky. Susan was lucky. Here are my questions. Although most of us are intuitively inclined to judge Mark more harshly than we would judge Susan, is this fair? Should luck influence how we judge Mark and Susan? Should Susan get off the hook of moral responsibility simply because her out of control car went into the bushes and not into a group of bystanders? If you think that she deserves a degree of responsibility, should it be more or less than that of Mark?
How would you respond to these questions if you were there that night?
___________________________________________________________
**Laurence (Larry) Houlgate is an emeritus professor of philosophy and former department chair at California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo. A California native, he received his B.A. at Cal State Los Angeles and an M.A. and Ph.D. in philosophy at UCLA.
His teaching and research specialties in philosophy include Philosophy of Law, Social Ethics, and the History of Philosophy.
Now in retirement after a 51-year teaching career, Larry is currently writing guidebooks for beginning philosophy students on the classics of philosophy. At this writing (2022), eight study guides have been published.
Larry recently published the 3rd Edition of Understanding Philosophy, a study guide for beginning students on philosophical methodology.
Another book project in the works is about the long history of belief in the existence of a life after death, and the futility of past attempts to provide philosophic, scientific or any rational proof to ground this belief.
He enjoys retirement, especially spending quality time with his wife (of 51 years), research and writing, going to the movies, beach walks, early morning swims, and occasionally competing in U.S. Masters and Senior Games swim meets.
______________________________________________________________
Further recommended reading:
Bernard Williams. “Moral Luck”. In Moral luck : philosophical papers, 1973-1980. Williams, Bernard, author 1981.
[Note: The phrase “moral luck” was first used by Bernard Williams in a lecture to the Aristotelian Society, originally published in The Aristotelian Society Supplementary, Volume 1, 1976.]
Thomas Nagel. “Luck and Ethics” Ed. by Statman, Daniel. Moral Luck. SUNY. 1993. (Williams’ essay and a response to Nagel is also in the Statman reader).
** You can read about Professor Houlgate’s many philosophical books here.

Interesting concept, premise and questions. However, the phrase *moral luck*seems somewhat disconnected to me. How so? Well, I don’t view luck and morality as having anything substantive to do with one another. These two pride-filled people wanted to show off their high-performance cars. Foresight would have suggested someone could have looked at the roadway ahead for, say, a quarter mile or so. Apparently, no one considered that. This detail involved neither luck nor morality. Planning? Caution? Sure. Certainly, the young man was unlucky and paid for lack of foresight. The “moral” of the story, if there is one, is roughly, *look before you drag race*. There are hundreds of deaths every year from people being careless or impatient behind the wheel.
Maybe, if I read Professor Houlgate’s book, I would “get” where he is coming from. I will consider that.
MORAL LUCK
by Larry Houlgate**
What would Classical Philosophers say about the cases of Mark and Susan? That is difficult to imagine, they had no access to Hot Rods nor Movies featuring teenagers and their cars to inspire them to ever think of this scenario, however those things, and we, do exist now!
They met at Midnight, it was a Teenage spectacle, everyone was there who could be there, all their friends and pretty well everyone who knew them, some of the spectators wished for Victory for one or the other ‘Gladiators’? And probably no one there wished any harm to anyone!
What they were about to do was illegal, they were determined to ignore that, they had no evil intent, the illegality just added to the Fun and excitement of the moment, they were teenagers possessing teenage invincibility surely this would shield them from harm? Which it always does until it doesn’t!
Susan slipped on the oil on the road and hit the bushes, Mark also slipped on the oil and killed someone and injured many.
Perhaps Susan was lucky, I think in he context of the event She was very lucky, she learned the lesson, what ever it is, but will only get a ticket, while poor Mark and his Father, their problems are just beginning! Think of the pain and anguish, (And anger) of the family’s of the deceased and the injured? so Mark will have the rest of his life to regret being there and doing what his teenage mind led him to that night.
Was any of this predictable? Not really, of course we shouldn’t break the Law but no one anticipated the oil on the road, did Mark mean to hurt anyone, of course not, yet really bad luck befell him and his family, something that will effect them for the rest of their lives!
I don’t think there are categories of luck, Luck effects us all, our first experience of Luck is the parents we are born to, if we are lucky we are born into a home where we are nurtured and loved and our brains are allowed develop, all the commentators on this site have had this experience, if you hadn’t you wouldn’t be here.
So Mark ‘and his family’ had some very bad luck indeed, is there anything anyone can do to improve their Luck? I don’t believe there is, but we have been lucky so far so why should it stop? Teenage invincibility keeps on working after the teenage era is long in the past, it keeps on working until it doesn’t, of course the wisdom of age cautions us not to consciously test it!
Most of the World is outside our conscious control, the only thing we have any hope of modifying are the thoughts in our minds”, Marcus Aurelius said something to this effect.
Dr. Messerly,
I hope this message finds you well.
And so, the unthinkable and the unimaginable is happening: through a series of extraordinary and rare events, such as the seeming blunders made by Biden being of course interpreted by the common crowd as ‘weakness’, and what has happened to Trump, it looks like Mr. Trump is on the way of his new presidency.
I wanted to write this message in the relevant post where you wrote to me that you hoped I was right, but I cannot find it, so excuse me the apparent ‘off topic’ message.
Indeed, I was completely wrong. We are surrounded by chaos.
Best wishes,
Luigi
”How would you respond to these questions if you were there that night?”
My answer: absolutely not, it is not fair: both Mark and Susan should be judged as harshly as possible, in equal measure. They both knew they could kill people, and if they didn’t, they should have, because neither was mentally impaired in any ways, and were not small children but adults.
And Susan helped Mark doing what the latter did, whether she could imagine the magnitude of that, or not.
I am not a lawyer, but in law for a defendant to be prosecuted successfully, two components must be satisfied, that a crime had been committed, and that the defendant was ‘mens rea’, i.e. aware that they were committing a crime. If one of these is not satisfied, the defendant would be very unlikely to be prosecuted.
Susan and Mark certainly knew they were doing something illegal, i.e. against the law. They broke the law, and willingly. Who ran their car into people, or who killed more people, isn’t that relevant, except that Mark, if he possess a conscience, will feel far more guilty than Susan. But this is a matter for the individual, not the law.
Only if Mark had – willingly – killed people, and Susan did not, should Mark get a harsher sentence.
But, as Dr. Messerly says, ‘I can be wrong’, although this would of course have to be demonstrated, but my aim here was simply to write what I thought about the matter, not entering a full debate, though this would be useful, but the problem is time and energy.
Thank you for reading.
” …because neither was mentally impaired in any ways”.
This would of course exclude intentional mental impairment, such as getting drunk or taking drugs: of course if Susan and Mark would have got drunk before racing, they should be punished even more harshly.
And to me, prison should only apply to the crimes like stealing, etc.
Not killing. But that’s another subject.
And there’s another point to make about the whole story: the people who were killed or injured, they themselves contributed to an illegal event taking place; they themselves contributed to ‘build the stage’ for their own deaths or injuries to happen.
Thus, they were partly responsible for their own deaths or injuries, because they knew what they were doing.
Presumably, the law says that this type of racing is illegal, precisely because it is dangerous. For professional racing happens only and exclusively with safety measures taking place.
So, I would say to Mark, Susan, and even the injured and the dead: ”You brought it upon yourself.”.
Mens rea, again.
Paul Van Pelt, I think it is a ‘Story’ based on the plot of a movie for teenagers, made in the fifties, I actually saw this movie, but I can’t remember the ending clearly, I do believe that one of the cars went over the cliff.
I think the lesson is; There are oily patches on Life’s road so be careful, that was the cautionary tale for Susan.
Mark didn’t die but I have no doubt that, in the context of the story as it is presented, he may have wished that he had, at least for a while, it is an allegorical story showing us that life is always risky, you never know when the oily patches will appear! Life lessons for the youth, I was thirteen or fourteen when I saw it, but of course I had teenage invincibility then so I knew that nothing really bad could ever happen to me.
Thank you Doctor John, commenting on these ‘Neutral’ subjects is great fun, I enjoy and respect your comments PVP.
build the stage= set the stage
Thanks for your remarks and insights, Mr Russell. I too seem to recall such a film. Teenage angst was a big topic and money maker in those years. I guess it still is, but, like us all, it has matured.
”…commenting on these ‘Neutral’ subjects is great fun…”.
Surely, subjects about death and people killing others, whether intentional or not, is great fun, I enjoy it more than playing videogames, which I find incredibly boring.
I am not sure what a ‘neutral subject’ is, but who am I to judge?